Butternut Squash Soup with Cider

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

Smooth and Creamy Butternut Squash Soup with Cider is fall comfort food at its best. Serve with crusty bread for a satisfying harvest meal.

Legendary Butternut Squash Soup with Cider

I have to admit two things when sharing this recipe with you.

I made a version of this recipe on the local TV morning show where I am a regular guest. The news anchor played a practical joke on me (while on air!). He announced to the Four State area that this soup tasted "terrible"! I will never live this recipe down. I may long be remembered for this recipe because he said it was bad. I'm sure far longer than people will remember all the good ones I've shared... Thanks, Dave Pilent. 🤣
I do love this soup. It is a great recipe and it's different than all of the other soups I make. I feel healthy when I eat it. It can easily be made vegetarian. That's gotta mean it's good for me, right?

I have made some adjustments to the recipe over the years and I think it's even better than the original I shared with Dave P (Brat!) back in the day. This is an easy soup that has a perfect balance of rich, creamy, sweet, and earthy.

So get out your stick blender and let's roast some Butternut Squash from your local farmers' market. This time of year, my favorite market growers, Misty and Charlie, make sure I get a couple of these beautiful squash to make this perfect soup.

The Ingredients (And Why They Matter)

The Garnishes (Pepitas, Copy Cat Crunchy Chili Onion, Croutons, or Creme Fraiche): Silky soup begs for contrast. Crunch, heat, and tang turn a bowl of puree into a full experience.

Butternut Squash: The star, and roasting it is the big thing. Dry oven heat concentrates the sugars and caramelizes the cut edges, so you get deep, nutty sweetness that boiled squash never delivers. Bonus: the roasted flesh scoops right out of the skin, so no peeling and no wrestling a raw squash with a knife.

Leeks: Milder and sweeter than onion, and they melt into the soup instead of announcing themselves. Cleaning them well matters, because sandy leeks are the fastest way to ruin a silky soup.

Tart Apple (Granny Smith): Squash is sweet and earthy and needs something bright to push back. A tart green apple adds that backbone and keeps the soup from tasting like baby food.

Apple Cider: This is the signature. It brings a fruity, slightly tangy depth that plain broth can't, and it ties the apple and squash together.

Chicken Broth (or Vegetable): The savory foundation. A good homemade stock makes this taste like it simmered all day.

Butter and Garlic: Butter softens the leeks and carries flavor. Garlic adds the savory note that keeps the soup from drifting into dessert territory.

The Spice Lineup (Allspice, Nutmeg, Cardamom, Cajun Seasoning): Warm spices make it taste like fall, and the cardamom adds an aromatic note people can't quite name. The Tony Chachere's is the sneaky one, adding a gentle savory kick and salt that rounds everything out.

Heavy Whipping Cream: Added at the end for body and a velvety finish. Because it goes in after blending, the soup stays luscious without tasting heavy.

Brown Sugar: Your dial for sweetness. Taste first. A sweet squash may not need it at all.

How to Clean a Leek

Slice the white end off the leek and discard the woody green portion. Slice the white portion lengthwise and rinse well between each layer to remove sand and dirt.

How to Make Butternut Squash Soup with Cider

1. Roast the Squash: Roast the halved, seeded squash on a baking sheet in a hot oven until completely tender. Roasting caramelizes the flesh and drives off excess water, which means more flavor and a thicker, less watery soup. Cool it just enough to handle, then scoop the flesh from the skins.

2. Build the Flavor Base: Melt the butter in a large pot and cook the leeks until soft. Go gently and don't let them brown, because scorched leeks turn bitter and that flavor will carry through the whole pot.

3. Simmer Everything Together: Add the squash, garlic, apple, broth, cider, and spices, then bring to a low boil. Simmer until the apples are soft. Soft apples blend completely smooth, while firm chunks leave a grainy texture. Take the pot off the heat and let it cool 5 to 10 minutes. This is a safety step, because blending boiling-hot liquid is how kitchens get splattered.

4. Blend Until Silky: Use a stick blender right in the pot, or work in batches in a stand blender with a folded towel over the lid so steam can escape. If it's too thick to blend, thin it with a splash of water until it moves freely.

5. Finish with Cream: Return the blended soup to the pot, stir in the cream and brown sugar, and warm gently over low heat. Keep it low so the cream doesn't curdle. Taste and add salt if it needs it.

6. Garnish Like You Mean It: Ladle into bowls and top with something crunchy and something with a little heat. Serve with crusty bread for dunking. Serve with a hunk of crusty bread for a complete meal.

butter and leeks in a pan for butternut squash soup.

"In a Pinch" Ingredient Swaps

Tony Chachere's: If you don't have it, a pinch of cayenne plus a little extra salt to get close.

Leeks: Sweet yellow onion or shallots can fill in. Flavor will be a touch sharper, so cook them low and slow.

Granny Smith Apple: Any firm, tart apple should work. A very sweet variety may need less brown sugar.

Chicken Broth: Vegetable broth keeps it vegetarian.

Heavy Cream: Half-and-half would give you a lighter soup, and canned full-fat coconut milk is an option for a dairy-free soup.

Apple Cider: Apple juice works in a pinch.

Soups to Try

Creative Variations

Smoky Bacon and Sage: Crisp bacon on top, with sage fried in the bacon fat or browned butter for a drizzle. Sweet squash and smoky pork is a natural pair.
Curried Butternut: Swap some of the warm spices for curry powder and finish with a swirl of coconut milk.
Maple Chipotle: Replace the brown sugar with a little maple syrup and add a pinch of chipotle for smoky heat.
Roasted Garlic Upgrade: Roast a whole head of garlic alongside the squash and blend it in for a mellow, sweet garlic backbone.
Soup and Sandwich Night: Skip the croutons and dunk grilled sharp cheddar and apple sandwiches instead.

Storage & Reheating

Can You Freeze It? Cream-based soups can separate a little after thawing, so I wouldn't freeze this one. Unless, you held off the cream for when you reheat it.
The Container Matters: Cool the soup first, then store it in shallow airtight containers so it chills quickly and evenly. If freezing, leave headspace because soup expands.
The Fridge Life: Keeps 3 to 5 days in the refrigerator. Reheat gently on the stove over low heat, stirring often, and thin with a splash of broth or water if it thickened up.

Cooking for One or Two

This recipe makes a big pot. Portion the leftovers into single-serving containers and you have fast lunches all week. Reheat a bowl on the stove or in the microwave, then add fresh crunchy toppings so it tastes just-made. A scoop of leftover soup also makes a great quick pasta sauce or a base for a pot of Homestyle Chili.

FAQ

Why does my soup taste too sweet?

Squash varies, and the apple, cider, and brown sugar all add sweetness. Taste before adding the brown sugar and skip it if the soup is already sweet. Brighten with a pinch of salt, an extra spoonful of chili-onion crunch, or a small squeeze of lemon.

Why is my cream soup stringy or gritty instead of silky?

Usually it's either undercooked apple or leftover bits of squash skin. Simmer until the apples are fully soft, scoop the flesh cleanly from the skins, and blend longer than you think you need to. A stand blender gives the smoothest result.

Why did my soup look curdled or separated after reheating?

Cream-based soups hate high heat. Reheat low and slow and stir often, and don't let it boil once the cream is in.

What to Serve With Butternut Squash Soup

Fresh Out of the Kitchen: What We're Cooking Right Now

DID YOU TRY THIS RECIPE?

Lastly, if you made Butternut Squash Soup with Cider following this recipe, please let me know how you liked it by leaving a comment and/or giving a rating!

I love hearing from you! I'll do my best to respond to each comment.

And of course, if you do make this recipe, tag @laughingroostereats on Instagram and hashtag it #laughingroostereats! Seeing your photos is our favorite thing!

Chuckie Hessong